Blogs

There is no "right" financial answer to the fellowship question, only a decision that aligns with an individual’s personal circumstances, priorities, and long-term career goals. By Dr. Kayla Knuf, with Drs. Joy Chen, Carly Jacobs, Sachin Jha, Eric Reilly, and Lisa Weiss

---

For anesthesiology residents, the decision to pursue fellowship training is rarely straightforward. While a passion for a subspecialty often sparks the conversation, financial considerations including debt, lost income, long-term earning potential, and job security frequently play a central role. To better understand how these factors influence decision making, we asked anesthesiologists at varying career stages, spanning both academic and private practice settings, to reflect on how finances factored into their fellowship choices.

The Financial Case Against Fellowship

The most immediate financial cost of fellowship training is the opportunity cost of deferring an attending salary. Forgoing a year of private practice income can be especially impactful for residents who are further along in life, supporting families, or managing significant debt. Contributors who elected not to pursue fellowship cited several practical advantages:

• Earlier income stability allowing for faster debt reduction and financial security.
• Early entry into investing and retirement savings benefiting from long-term compounding.

For physicians pursuing a broad-based academic or community practice, fellowship training was not viewed as financially essential. With robust residency preparation and thoughtful elective selection, these anesthesiologists felt well equipped to practice across a wide scope without subspecialty credentials allowing for immediate workforce entry while maintaining versatility.

That said, some degree of long-term uncertainty persists. Ongoing concerns about market consolidation, scope expansion, and evolving credentialing expectations represent potential future risks that may influence career flexibility over time.

The Financial Case for Fellowship 

Those who pursued fellowship training consistently reframed the financial question beyond the loss of a single year of income. Rather than focusing on short-term salary differentials, they asked broader questions: Would this make me harder to replace? Would it expand my career options over the next 30 years? Would it increase my professional fulfillment?

From this perspective, fellowship offered several perceived financial advantages:

• Enhanced job security in an increasingly competitive and consolidating market.
• Access to specialized call pools and administrative roles.
• Greater negotiating leverage through differentiated skills.
• Eligibility for positions that require or strongly prefer fellowship training.

Many contributors described fellowship as a career multiplier rather than a direct pay raise. While few reported immediate salary bumps, many noted downstream benefits including greater autonomy, leadership opportunities, and increased leverage in shaping their professional environment.

The Bottom Line

Across all responses, personal circumstances proved to be the most important factor in decisions about fellowship training. The same fellowship year can feel vastly different depending on debt load, family responsibilities, relationship considerations, household income structure, and long-term career goals. Several contributors emphasized that financial stress during fellowship is not only a numerical concern, but it can also meaningfully affect burnout, personal relationships, and long-term professional satisfaction.

On the other hand, avoiding a fellowship purely to escape short term financial discomfort may carry its own cost, potentially leading to decades of professional misalignment. From a purely financial standpoint, fellowship training is rarely a right or wrong choice. Instead, it’s a trade-off that depends on honest self-reflection and where you see your career heading. Ultimately, the most financially sound decision is the one that enables you to build a sustainable, fulfilling career over the long-term.

Kayla Knuf, MD is a board certified anesthesiologist who practices in Texas.

The ASA Committee on Young Physicians is pleased to present this monthly article series on personal finance. These articles are not written by hedge fund managers or real estate tycoons but by practicing physicians. Some have business degrees and some do not – but every contributor is an anesthesiologist who has some guidance to offer the rising generation of attending physicians. It is not the intention of the committee to offer definitive financial advice, but rather some pearls of wisdom to consider while developing a personal fiscal plan. 

#CommitteeonYoungPhysicians
#PersonalFinances