Blogs

Physicians spend years protecting patients, building careers, and accumulating assets. Yet many of us overlook one relatively inexpensive layer of protection that can become critically important as income and net worth grow: Umbrella Insurance. By Kayla Knuf, MD

---

Simply put, umbrella insurance is extra insurance that provides protection beyond the existing limits and coverages of your other insurance policies (homeowners, auto). These policies function as excess liability coverage, meaning they typically require specific minimum limits on your underlying auto and homeowners policies.

It can help to protect your assets in two ways. First, it may provide additional liability protection when the limits of your other policies have been exhausted. Second, it may provide coverage for certain personal liability claims not typically included under auto or homeowners policies (false arrest, wrongful eviction, invasion of privacy, libel, slander). Many policies also provide legal defense coverage for covered claims, which can be valuable even if a lawsuit ultimately does not result in a large settlement.

Importantly, umbrella insurance does not extend to professional liability. These policies exclude medical malpractice claims, professional negligence, and claims arising from patient care. In these situations, your malpractice policy remains your primary protection for your clinical practice. Umbrella policies also have exclusions and may not cover intentional actions, business-related liability, or certain high-risk activities.

An Example of Umbrella Insurance

You get into a major car accident with multiple injuries and are found to be at fault. Your auto policy covers up to $500,000 in liability but total damages are $1.8 million. Without umbrella coverage, you could personally owe the remaining $1.3 million.

Why Should You Care?

High-income professionals, including physicians, may be perceived as having substantial assets or future earning potential, which can increase concern about personal liability exposure. By mid-career, many anesthesiologists have retirement accounts, brokerage accounts, properties, and business ownership which are at risk from personal liability claims. While certain assets may have varying degrees of legal protection depending on state law, umbrella insurance can still help reduce exposure to personal financial loss and litigation risk.

Furthermore, high-income earners are more likely to have higher lifestyle risk (pools, boats, vacation homes, employees, frequent travel, rental properties) increasing the potential liability exposure.

When Should You Get It? How Much Coverage Do You Need?

You should consider getting umbrella insurance in your early attending years. After the transition from resident to attending salary, your assets, and therefore your financial exposure, can accumulate rapidly. Other things you should consider when deciding when to buy a policy – home ownership, the purchase of "attractive nuisances" such as pools or trampolines, and the addition of teen drivers. These factors can increase liability exposure, making additional protection advantageous.

The appropriate amount of coverage depends on individual assets, lifestyle, and risk exposure. It should reflect your exposed assets and future earnings potential. For many anesthesiologists, a $2-5 million policy is common.

How Expensive Is It? Can I Shop Around?

It depends. Higher coverage limits generally result in higher premiums. Several additional factors also influence pricing. For example, luxury cars, poor driving history, larger homes, pools, and dog ownership can factor into your cost. Most people end up paying between $400-1500 per year depending on their coverage selection and liability exposure risk.

Shopping around can be limited, as many carriers require you to bundle your auto and homeowners/renters insurance with the same company to obtain umbrella coverage. Additionally, insurance companies often require minimum coverage limits on auto and homeowners/renters policies to be eligible for umbrella insurance.

Why Should I Do It?

Umbrella insurance is a simple and cost-effective way anesthesiologists can protect the life they have worked years to build. While malpractice insurance protects your clinical practice, umbrella insurance helps protect your personal assets and future earning potential from catastrophic liability claims outside the operating room - most commonly from motor vehicle accidents or injuries occurring on your property. For many physicians, a few hundred dollars per year can provide millions in additional protection, making umbrella insurance a thoughtful component of long-term financial planning.

Kayla Knuf, MD is a board certified anesthesiologist who practices in Texas.

The ASA Committee on Young Physicians is pleased to present this monthly article series on personal finance. These articles are not written by hedge fund managers or real estate tycoons but by practicing physicians. Some have business degrees and some do not – but every contributor is an anesthesiologist who has some guidance to offer the rising generation of attending physicians. It is not the intention of the committee to offer definitive financial advice, but rather some pearls of wisdom to consider while developing a personal fiscal plan.

#CommitteeonYoungPhysicians
#PersonalFinances